Nature's Confluence
  • Blog
  • Our Goals
  • Contributors
    • Ryan Peek
    • Casey Peters
    • Mike Peterson
    • Kat Powelson
    • Mark Schwartz
    • Dena Spatz
    • Anna Steel
    • Zack Steel
    • Matt Williamson
  • Brain Eddies

Nature's Confluence
Navigating the Turbulence of conservation

What Noel should have said

7/7/2017

3 Comments

 
Mark Schwartz
I just wrote to lambast Mike Noel for this quote: “When we turn the Forest Service over to the bird and bunny lovers and the tree huggers and the rock lickers, we’ve turned our history over. We are going to lose our wildlife and we are going to lose our scenery, the very thing you people wanted to try to protect. It’s just plain stupidity.” Mostly, I focused on what he got wrong.

Today I take a more positive look at what he could have said that would have been constructive and more accurate, and likely accomplish what he wanted to in the process.


First, it seems like a bad idea to resort to demeaning constituents through name calling. I am a bird lover, and a tree hugger and I don't mind people calling me that. However, Mr. Noel clearly has a derogatory intent in his usage of these terms. This immediately alienates a set of people and unhelpfully draws a line between us and them. Any kind of solution in a contested issue is eased when we can get us to agree with them, better yet, to blur the lines between us and them. So, why draw that line. He should have said that historical choices that may have made sense at the time have led to unintended consequences that I think we can all agree are undesirable. This is both true and coalition building rather than opposition line forming.

Second, focusing on the past without looking to the future is a mistake. The Rep. Noel focused his rant (you can see the video here) on what he thinks are bad decisions of the past. His focus is on people's vacation homes, resort villages and the tax base of the counties he represents. Fair enough, he should worry about the tax base. However, vacation home owners are, in point of fact, generally very vocal in their opposition to logging on public lands adjoining their property. It lowers their home values, and, by the way, the tax base. Just as ski resorts like forests, but not logging operations. This is a nuanced issue that is simply not helped by painting it as good (e.g., forest management that includes a healthy amount of logging) versus evil (e.g., forest management that does not include logging). 

Third, doesn't everyone want to seek solutions? Mike Noel's summary statement about the future and solutions was, "...and now we have a president that can do something about it." to paraphrase. Not very helpful.

What, exactly should the President, Secretary of Agriculture, or Secretary of Interior do? Increase timber sales around vacation homes? That would work, but good luck with the political fallout from that.

These are tough issues that require tough negotiations and tough solutions. We know that fire suppression has resulted in increased fuels. We know that increased ignitions makes the problem harder. We know that climatic conditions are becoming more favorable to high fire intensity. We know that reduced logging has exacerbated the fire issue. We also know that logging pines in the west has become a marginal economic operation in many locations. We also know that there are many environmentalists that oppose actions that result in reducing fuel loads in forests. We know that we lack the capacity to get a handle on this through the increased use of prescribed fire.

We have people from all perspectives working on solutions. We know that we have a lot of hard work ahead of us to get these interventions implemented. We know that time is not our friend as we have increasing numbers of these events through time. Mike Noel should have told us all about those things rather than lambasted a caricatured group of people that he both chastises and calls his constituents. Simplifying the issue into overly simplistic and caricatured sides is polarizing and inaccurate. Finally, polarizing an issue is the easiest way to stop policy reform in its tracks. 

3 Comments
uk essay writing companies link
8/10/2017 10:57:06 pm

I read this article in which you give information about the forest and agriculture things. I add some another thing like politics. The good thing is that you did the wonderful job and your maturity level is so lovely. I enjoyed this article so much.

Reply
uk best essay writing service link
9/13/2017 08:09:28 am

I used your article to write my essay. I hope you do not mind. I agree with you completely. In general, I want to say ...For example, you've got an essay to write. Writing an essay isn't a mean task. Now, based on how many pages your essay should be, just concentrate on a section at one time and offer some evidence.

Reply
Warriors Leather Vest link
9/15/2017 05:46:44 am

Your blogs shares the quality content material to sharing with buddies and the encounter trend through and large applies to a present fashion of outward display, but quite regularly applies to a non-public mode of look that could or won't stick to conventional ideals.

Reply



Leave a Reply.

    Categories

    All
    Author: Anna Steel
    Author: Casey Peters
    Author: Dena Spatz
    Author: Kat Powelson
    Author: Mark Schwartz
    Author: Matt Williamson
    Author: Mike Petterson
    Author: Ryan Peek
    Author: Zack Steel
    Climate Change
    Conservation
    Education
    Evolution
    Genetics
    Genomics
    Natural History
    Natural Resource Management
    Salmon

    Archives

    July 2017
    June 2017
    May 2017
    November 2016
    October 2016
    September 2016
    August 2016
    July 2016
    June 2016
    May 2016
    April 2016
    March 2016
    February 2016
    January 2016
    December 2015
    November 2015
    October 2015

    RSS Feed

    Google chrome users: click here to download a RSS extension
Proudly powered by Weebly
  • Blog
  • Our Goals
  • Contributors
    • Ryan Peek
    • Casey Peters
    • Mike Peterson
    • Kat Powelson
    • Mark Schwartz
    • Dena Spatz
    • Anna Steel
    • Zack Steel
    • Matt Williamson
  • Brain Eddies
✕